Courtesy Car & Legal Cover: Are They Worth The Extra Cost?

Summary

• Courtesy Car Cover: Provides a temporary vehicle during repairs after a covered accident. It's usually a basic model and does not apply if your car is stolen or written off.
• Motor Legal Protection: Covers solicitors' fees to recover uninsured losses (e.g., policy excess, loss of earnings) after a non-fault accident. It is extremely cost-effective.
• Hire Car Cover: A more comprehensive (and expensive) add-on that provides a replacement vehicle if your car is written off or stolen, often of a similar size to your own.
• Proactive Checks: Before insuring a car, performing a vehicle history check is crucial to identify hidden issues like a write-off history or outstanding finance.

You've found a great car insurance quote, you're ready to buy, and then the "optional extras" page appears. It’s a list of things that sound vaguely important: Motor Legal Protection, Courtesy Car Cover, Key Cover, Excess Protection...

Your mouse hovers. Your mind races. Is this a scam? Do I actually need any of this?

It’s a familiar feeling. These add-ons aren't designed to trip you up, but they're often poorly explained, leaving you to guess their true value. Today, we're pulling back the curtain on the two most common—and most confusing—add-ons: Courtesy Car Cover and Motor Legal Protection.

We’ll break down what they really offer, when they’re a lifesaver, and when they’re just dead weight on your premium.

Stranded or Sorted? Demystifying Courtesy Car Cover

On the surface, it seems simple. If your car is in the garage, the insurer gives you another one. What could be wrong with that? Well, the devil is in the details.

A courtesy car is a temporary vehicle provided by your insurer while your car is being repaired after a covered accident. That’s the key part. It’s designed to keep you mobile, but its limitations can come as a nasty surprise.

The Big "Buts" of Courtesy Car Cover

Before you tick that box, you need to know what you’re not getting.

• It’s Not for Write-Offs or Theft: This is the biggest misconception. If your car is stolen and never seen again, or if it's declared a total loss (a write-off), you will not get a courtesy car under this standard cover. The agreement is for the repair period only. Once the car is gone for good, the loaner goes back.
• You Must Use Their Garage: Insurers have networks of approved repairers. To get the courtesy car, you have to use one of them. If you have a trusted local mechanic you’d rather use, you’ll likely forfeit the right to a replacement vehicle.
• Expect a Downgrade: Are you driving a 7-seater SUV? Tough. You’re probably getting a 1.0-litre, 3-door hatchback. The car provided is almost always a small, basic model. It'll get you from A to B, but it won't be a like-for-like replacement.
• Check the Insurance Terms: You might assume the courtesy car is covered on your comprehensive policy, just like your own car. Check this! Some insurers only provide third-party cover for the courtesy vehicle, even if you have a fully comp policy. That's a huge risk you need to be aware of.

Courtesy Car vs. Hire Car Cover: What's the Difference?

This is where insurers could be clearer. "Hire Car Cover" is a separate, more robust add-on that provides greater protection.

So, is Courtesy Car Cover Worth It?

It depends entirely on your life.

• It’s probably worth it if: You have only one car, you rely on it for your commute or the school run, and you live somewhere with poor public transport. The thought of being without wheels for two weeks fills you with dread.
• It might not be worth it if: You have access to another car, you work from home, or a tiny hatchback is useless for your needs (e.g., you're a tradesperson with lots of gear). In that case, the more expensive Hire Car Cover might be the only sensible option.

The Legal Lifeline: Why Motor Legal Protection is a No-Brainer

Okay, this one sounds boring, doesn't it? "Motor Legal Protection." But stick with me, because for around £20-£30 a year, this add-on is one of the best-value products in insurance.

In short, it pays for your solicitor's fees to recover costs after an accident that wasn't your fault.

"But my main insurance covers that, right?" Wrong. Your standard policy is designed to fix your car and cover liability to others. It doesn't help you with what the industry calls "uninsured losses."

What Are "Uninsured Losses"?

These are the sneaky, out-of-pocket expenses that crop up after a crash:

• Your Policy Excess: That £400 you had to pay to get the claim started? Legal cover helps you claim it back from the at-fault driver's insurer.
• Loss of Earnings: If you're off work for a week with whiplash, this cover helps you sue for the wages you lost.
• Personal Injury Compensation: Beyond immediate medical care, it covers the legal costs of seeking compensation for injuries.
• Damaged Belongings: Was your laptop or child's car seat damaged in the crash? This helps you recover the cost.
• Other Transport Costs: The cost of taxis or public transport while you were without a car.

Without this cover, you’d have to hire a solicitor yourself or use a "no win, no fee" service.

The "No Win, No Fee" Myth

"No win, no fee" sounds great, but it’s not free. If you win, these firms can take up to 25% of your compensation as their success fee. If you win £10,000, you could lose £2,500 of it.

With Motor Legal Protection, you typically keep 100% of your compensation. The insurance pays your legal team directly. That alone makes it worth the price of a few coffees.

The only catch? Your insurer will only take on a case if they believe you have a reasonable prospect of success (usually defined as 51% or better). They won't fund a hopeless legal battle.

Is Motor Legal Protection Worth It?

For the vast majority of drivers, yes, absolutely.

The peace of mind of knowing you have up to £100,000 of legal firepower on your side for less than £30 a year is immense. It transforms a potentially ruinous legal fight into a manageable process.

The Bigger Picture: Proactive Protection Starts Before You Buy

Choosing the right insurance add-ons is a reactive measure. But the smartest move you can make is proactive. It starts the moment you consider buying a used car.

Before you even think about insurance, you need to know the vehicle's story. Is it a former write-off (`Cat N` or `Cat S`)? Has it been stolen? Is there outstanding finance tied to it from a previous owner?

Uncovering these issues isn't just about negotiating a better price; it's about understanding the risk you're about to insure. A car with a hidden past could lead to more reliability issues, complex claims, and even legal nightmares that insurance can't fix. For example, if you unknowingly buy a car with an active finance agreement, the finance company could repossess it, leaving you with no car and no money.

This is where a thorough history check becomes your first, and most important, line of defence. Finding the best service for car history checks online isn't just a box-ticking exercise; it's fundamental to making an informed decision. A comprehensive vehicle history check gives you the data you need to assess the risk properly and choose the right level of cover, from the core policy right down to the add-ons.

So, What's the Verdict?

Insurance add-ons aren't a one-size-fits-all solution. Their value is personal.

• Courtesy Car Cover is for convenience. Assess your daily routine and decide if you can truly cope without a car.
• Motor Legal Protection is for financial security. For its tiny cost, it offers a massive safety net against the unexpected.

Next time you’re on that "optional extras" page, don't just guess. Think about your life, your needs, and just as importantly, the true history of the car you're protecting.

Read our other articles: