Apple CarPlay vs Android Auto vs Your Car's System

Summary

• Phone Mirroring vs Native Systems: Apple CarPlay and Android Auto project a simplified phone interface onto your car's screen, while a native system is the car's built-in OS that controls core vehicle functions.
• Apple CarPlay: Offers a simple, consistent, and clean user interface that's incredibly easy to use for iPhone owners, excelling in ecosystem integration.
• Android Auto: Provides powerful multitasking with a split-screen view, superior navigation via Google Maps, and greater app choice, but can feel more complex than CarPlay.
• Native Car Systems: Excel at deep vehicle integration (climate, drive modes) and work without a phone, but quality, app support, and update frequency can vary significantly between manufacturers.

You get into a new car, and there it is. A big, glossy screen staring back at you. The salesperson probably called it an "infotainment system," which sounds about as exciting as "nutritional paste."

But this screen is the new battleground for your car's soul. It's a three-way tug-of-war between what the carmaker built, what Apple thinks you need, and what Google is certain you want.

So, what's the deal? Is your car's built-in system any good, or should you just plug in your phone and let it take over? Let's break down the big infotainment showdown: Apple CarPlay vs Android Auto vs the manufacturer's own system.

First, What Are We Even Talking About?

This can get confusing, so let's make it simple.

Think of your car's native infotainment system as its built-in operating system. Like Windows on a PC or macOS on a Mac. It's deeply wired into the car's hardware. It controls the radio, the climate, and can tell you your tyre pressure.

Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are different. They aren't full operating systems for your car. They're more like applications that run on top of the car's system. When you plug in your phone, your car's screen essentially becomes a simplified, touch-friendly monitor for your phone. Your phone is doing all the heavy lifting – the mapping, the music streaming, the thinking. The car just provides the screen and speakers.

So, the real choice is: do you use the car's brain, or your phone's?

Apple CarPlay: Your iPhone on Four Wheels

If you have an iPhone, CarPlay is Apple's answer to in-car tech. And it is, in a word, Apple.

The Vibe

It’s clean. It’s simple. It’s a grid of familiar, rounded icons. If you can use an iPhone, you can use CarPlay in about five seconds. There’s no real learning curve. You plug it in (or connect wirelessly in newer cars), and your screen transforms into a distilled version of your phone's home screen.

What's it Good At?

• Simplicity: It’s incredibly easy to use. The menus are logical, the targets are big, and it’s designed from the ground up to not overwhelm you while you’re trying to navigate a tricky roundabout.
• Ecosystem Integration: If your life is run on Apple's calendar, podcasts, music, and messages, CarPlay is a dream. Siri reads your texts to you, you can reply with your voice, and it all just works seamlessly.
• Consistency: This is a big one. CarPlay looks and feels the same whether you’re in a £15,000 Vauxhall or a £150,000 Porsche. It provides a reliable, predictable experience no matter the vehicle.

What's Not So Great?

• The Walled Garden: Apple keeps a tight leash on CarPlay. You can only use apps that Apple has approved, which means your choices for navigation and music are more limited than on Android Auto.
• Minimal Customisation: You can change the wallpaper and move the icons around. That's about it. If you like to tinker, you're out of luck.
• Siri's Quirks: While Siri is great for simple commands ("Call Mum"), it can sometimes get flustered with more complex requests compared to its Google rival.

Side Note: Can I watch Netflix on CarPlay?
Nope. And you shouldn't want to. Apple (and Google) block video apps for the very obvious reason that watching The Crown while doing 70mph on the M1 is a terrible idea. Safety first!

Android Auto: Google's Co-Pilot

Android Auto is Google's vision for the car, and it feels exactly like you'd expect: powerful, a bit more open, and deeply integrated with all things Google.

The Vibe

It’s more dynamic than CarPlay. The "Coolwalk" interface, which is now standard, gives you a split-screen layout. This means you can have your map on one side of the screen and your music controls on the other. It’s incredibly useful and makes you feel like you have a proper command centre.

What's it Good At?

• Google Maps & Waze: Let’s be honest, this is the killer feature. Google Maps is the undisputed king of navigation, with brilliant real-time traffic and routing. Having it natively on your car screen is fantastic.
• Google Assistant: Google's voice assistant is, frankly, smarter than Siri. It's better at understanding natural language and handling complex queries like, "Find a petrol station on my route that has a coffee shop."
• Flexibility: Android Auto gives you more freedom. You have a wider choice of apps, and you can customise the look and feel a lot more than you can with CarPlay.

What's Not So Great?

• A Bit More Cluttered: That powerful split-screen view can sometimes feel a little busy compared to CarPlay's zen-like simplicity.
• The "Safety" Nanny: Android Auto can be a bit aggressive with its safety features. For example, it often limits how many times you can tap the screen or scroll through a playlist while moving, forcing you to use voice commands. It's for your own good, but it can be frustrating.
• Consistency Issues: Because it has to work on so many different screen shapes and sizes from countless carmakers, it can sometimes feel a little less polished than CarPlay.

Head-to-Head: The Big Comparison

So, how do they stack up on the things that really matter?

So, What About the Car's Own System?

It's easy to dismiss the manufacturer's system as old-fashioned. And a few years ago, you'd have been right. Many were slow, ugly, and had navigation that would get you lost in your own driveway.

But things have changed. A lot.

The Good Stuff

• Deep Integration: This is the native system's superpower. It can control things your phone can't, like the car's climate control, heated seats, ambient lighting, and drive modes. Everything is in one place.
• No Phone Needed: It works without your phone. This means you still have navigation if you forget your phone, its battery is dead, or you're driving through an area with zero signal. A lifesaver on some rural UK roads!
• They're Getting Good! Premium brands like BMW (with iDrive), Mercedes (MBUX), and Audi have invested billions in their systems. They are now fast, beautiful, and packed with features. They can even show navigation turns on the driver's display or the head-up display—something CarPlay and Android Auto are only just starting to do.

The Not-So-Good Stuff

• The Quality Lottery: While the premium German brands have nailed it, the quality of native systems elsewhere is a mixed bag. Some are still frustratingly slow and confusing.
• The Update Problem: Your phone's apps are updated constantly. Your car's system? Not so much. Map updates can be infrequent and sometimes even cost money after the first few years. This can be a real headache, especially with the constant changes on UK roads and the expansion of schemes like London's ULEZ.
• Clunky Apps: The built-in apps for things like music or podcasts are almost always inferior to the versions on your phone.

The Plot Twist: Android Automotive
This is where it gets really confusing. Android Automotive is not the same as Android Auto. It is a full operating system made by Google that carmakers (like Volvo and Polestar) are building directly into their cars. Think of it as a native system powered by Google. It has Google Maps and Google Assistant built-in, no phone required. It's the best of both worlds, and it's probably the future.

The Final Verdict: Which One is Actually Best?

Okay, let's cut to the chase.

The "best" system depends entirely on you and your priorities.

• If you live and breathe Apple, just use CarPlay. It’s designed for you. It’s seamless, simple, and does exactly what you need it to do with zero fuss.
• If you're an Android user who loves customisation and Google's ecosystem, you'll probably prefer Android Auto. Its navigation is top-tier, and it gives you more freedom.
• The car's native system is best when... it's a really good one (like the latest from BMW or Mercedes), and you want to control deep vehicle functions, or you're somewhere with no phone signal.

But for most people in 2024, the real answer is this: the best infotainment system is one that gives you a choice.

The ideal car has a solid, fast native system for core car functions, but also offers both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto as standard. This gives you the ultimate flexibility. You can use the car's built-in nav for a trip through the Peak District where the signal is dodgy, then switch to CarPlay to listen to your podcasts on the motorway commute.

The battle for your dashboard isn't about one system winning. It's about your car finally catching up with the powerful, connected computer you already carry in your pocket.

Read our other articles: